One common criticism of the CE – as designed and implemented today – is that it focuses too much on recycling over “refuse, reduce, and rethink” strategies. By not prioritising or emphasising upstream waste reduction strategies, most initiatives in the current production system still focus on incremental resource use optimisation strategies, instead of challenging the continued use of resources overall.
Unfortunately, optimising a broken system does not fix it. In the end, all we achieve is a slightly faster/cheaper/less resource-intensive… but no less broken system.
In this context, the CE may simply keep enabling a culture of consumerism and waste, further fueling inequalities and resource depletion. Addressing this requires a shift in our current systems of production and consumption, which can be facilitated by embracing a sufficiency-based Circular Economy.
Esra Tat, Executive Director of Zero Waste Europe